The Mighty Blobtop
by Steve Kelly
Reprinted from "Crown Jewels of the Wire", November 2001, page 28
I started collecting insulators when I was young and considered myself a
general collector. Around 1984 I was invited to go on my first insulator hike on
the Military Telegraph line near Fort Apache, AZ. It was on this trip that I
found my first insulator that the collecting hobby commonly refers to as the
"Blobtop", the CD126. Although our goal for the weekend was to find
EC&M's, I was happy to find the upper half of an olive green blob still
attached to the telegraph wire that was installed in the late 1870's. Over the
next several years my son Dave became interested and we were able to find more
blobs on this line, the most notable being a yellow olive with amber swirls.
Ever since then my interest in blobs has grown. My collection now leans toward
this style.
Photo by Chris Seamons.
There is not a lot of information readily available for the CD126 or its
close cousin the CD126.1. Most of my observations are from ones in my collection
or from conversations with other collectors. In no way would I consider this
study complete because it's continually growing as I am always adding to it as I
learn more. Any insight would be welcomed. I am providing this information along
with some photos of the better-colored and character pieces to help document and
show the variety available for this unique style. I also must add that not all
these pieces reside in my collection.
When you review all the embossings that
are recorded for these two styles, you find 55+ for the CD126 and only one for
the CD126.1. The origin of the CD126.1 is solely Brookfield. I will discuss this
style later. The majority of the CD126's were also Brookfield, but some exist
that have unknown manufacturers. These are the ones that are categorized as no
names or no embossing. The no embossed unit [010] has a large round dome which
has a shape unlike any Brookfield piece I have seen. There is also a drip point
at the top of the pinhole, which is not a characteristic of a Brookfield piece.
Now the no embossed [020] with a MLOD is definitely Brookfield because of the
shape of the dome and the swirled threads along with the mold line over the
dome. I have not seen the Pennycuick [030] style or the no name [010] with a 7
{large number}. The skirt embossed RD149959 origin also remains unknown. What is
known is that all non-Brookfields are considered scarce to rare.
Cover Photo
Overall
Brookfield embossings vary greatly. The collecting hobby will probably never
fully identify and record all the slight variations that exist. All embossings
make reference to the location of New York. Generally speaking Brookfield blobs
can be categorized into four groups. The two dome embossed versions that either
contain "55 FULTON ST" address, or the "45 CLIFF ST"
address, the skirt embossed "W BROOKFIELD NEW YORK", and the ones with
no embossing. Production started with 55 Fulton, changed to 45 Cliff when the
company moved and ended around 1908 while they were still located in New York
and while William Brookfield was still alive.
When comparing blobs you find that
the dome size and shape along with the over all height varies greatly in the
earlier two piece mold dome embossed styles. The tops of the dome can be flat or
pointy. One thing I have noticed on all blobs is that due to the shape of the
dome the flat part at the top of the pinhole is reflected when backlit and
appears to be a bubble. The number of threads also depends on how much glass was
put in the mold. Occasionally you can find examples that have had extra glass to
the point where the skirt is only about a half inch deep. The threads can have 11 revolutions in these. That might be a record. The
typical skirt depth is around 1" to 1-1/4" inches with 7 threads.
Embossing is typically weak. The later skirt embossed styles are shorter more
uniform and were made from three-piece molds. Their height varies up to a
quarter inch, which is due to the amount of glass that was formed below the
skirt's mold line. Embossing tends to be weak on these too.
You can find at
least 10 different patent date combinations on the Brookfield CD126's. Not all
of them are correct. Embossings typically contain one, two, or three dates. The
mold engravers would occasionally mix them up. Brookfield also liked to use
quotes " instead of duplicating the months and years when multiple dates
were embossed above and below each other. Besides the patent dates you can
occasionally find a "backward S" in the abbreviation for street. PAT
abbreviated with two T's or an "I" instead of a "P". Cauvet
misspelled with a "D" instead of a "C". The "k"
left out of Brookfield, and Brookfield misspelled with an "E" instead
of a "B".
The correct patent dates that are consistent with other styles:
JUL 25 1865
|
JAN 25 1870
|
FEB 22 1870
|
FEB 22, 70
|
MARCH 20 1877
|
JAN 14 1879
|
And the wrong ones with the noted error, some are unique to the CD 126:
JAN 14 1870
|
-- the 1870 should be 1879
|
MARCH 20 1870
|
-- the 1870 should be
1877
|
MARCH 22 1877
|
-- the 22 should be 20
|
FEB 22 1879
|
-- the 1879 should be 1870
|
JAN 25 1879
|
-- the 1879 should be 1870
|
Colors can range from the common, light blues and aqua ones, to the
outstanding greens, yellow greens, olive greens and yellow olive amber ones, to
the unbelievable purple, dark red and yellow ambers. There are only a handful of
the purple ones with even fewer of the ambers.
The purple blobs were primarily
found in Utah (and some in the southern states). During 1982-1985 two purple and
three yellow olive amber ones were found on the Military Telegraph line near Ft.
Apache, AZ. At the Y2K National a purple CD126 was brought in that was bought at a local antique store. The only known red amber is believed to have
been found in Canada, as were many of the deeper greens and olives. At the 2000
Eastern Regional a gray/green tint un-embossing blob surfaced. It was purchased
off the Internet. This unusual color is similar to the silvery ice green CD143's
and is believed to be Canadian.
CD126 Blobtops were as popular in the late 19th
century as Hemingray 42's were in the mid 20th century. They were popular out
west and can still be found just about anywhere in the United States and Canada.
They were typically used along railroads and early telegraph lines and were also
used as replacement glass for lines that were originally strung with EC&M's
and CAL ELEC WORK insulators.
Which came first -- the CD126 or the CD126.1?
Having recently acquired my CD126.1, I wanted to investigate how these
straight skirt blobtop variants fit in the Brookfield production. First thing I
did was go to the embossing variations listed in the McDougald's 1999 Price
Guide. I am suggesting the following knowing that it is pure speculation on my
part. Still, I think I have some worthy points. I am going to continue
researching my finding by looking for clues that either support or disprove my
opinions.
There is only one embossing listed for the CD126.1. Note that the
1870-year patent date is abbreviated as 70, and that there is also a number
reference (NO) to the 55 Fulton street address. What other styles has these
characteristics? The number reference occurs often, but the abbreviated date
does not. There are only three styles with 70. The CD's: 127, 126.1, and 126.
Why only these three? What do they have in common? Embossing variations had to
have been kept fairly consistent from year to year on all insulator designs
being manufactured. The only exception would be if a specific customer had a
specific request. I think that this is unlikely, because it's too consistent
with all the other standard Brookfield embossing, (company, street address, and
patent dates).
Review the listings for the CD127 and CD126. Each has several
listings with 70. Different listings means multiple molds equaling lots of
insulators being produced. Now look at the CD126.1, which is considered kind of
scarce. Only one is listing with two color variations. This would suggest that
the production run was very limited, why? Perhaps experimental pieces during a
design review?
Duane Davenport took this photo of me next to one of the
iron poles that were
placed in 1883 to replace the aging wood poles.
The cross arm is where the
lineman stood to service the line.
I believe the CD 127 is the older design being produced first. For some
reason there was a need for a design change. The dome was reworked increasing
its size along with the wire groove. The straight skirt shape was left alone.
The CD 126.1 was born. The customers or engineers were still not satisfied. In
reviewing all CD's there are not that many that have straight skirts with larger
domes. After a short production run the design was changed again with a flared
skirt, the "mighty" CD126 Blobtop. This new design proved so
successful that the original CD127 design was eventually dropped. The CD127 was
discontinued and never produced after the company changed addresses to 45 Cliff
St.
The blobtop succeeded.... millions were made.
- - - - - - - - - -
I would like to thank Dwayne Anthony, Tommy Bolack, Fred Collier, Bob Fuqua,
Jim Meyer, Daryl Richardson and the John McDougald for supplying some of the
exotic pictures that I will only dream of having and Kevin Jacobson who
photographed the insulators in my collection used in this article.
The Mighty "Blobtop"
|
Light green, amber strings. |
Light green, amber tones. |
|
Blue aqua with amber swirls -
Jim Meyer. |
Green aqua with large amber
streak -
Dwayne Anthony. |
|
"Milky Way" of skirt snow. |
Fizzy green aqua.
|
|
Light green with snow, bubbles and amber. |
Bubbly green aqua
-
Bob Fuqua. |
|
Emerald green. |
Dark yellow green. |
|
Chartreuse. |
Yellow olive -
Fred Collier. |
Yellow olive amber with the original tie wire.
On his first hunt, Steve located the upper half of
an olive CD 126
"blobtop" still attached to the tie wire.
|
Yellow olive -
Tommy Bolack. |
Dark olive amber -
Dwayne Anthony.
|
|
Only one of these RED AMBER beauties has ever been found. And, this CD 126
pinnacle piece is in the collection of Dwayne Anthony. |
|
|
This unembossed CD 126 has
Canadian origins and was purchased in an eBay auction last year by Daryl
Richardson. It has a mold line over the dome and the grey green color is
similar to unembossed CD 143 MLOD Canadian beehives. |
|
Purple -
Tommy Bolack. |
Dark purple -
Dwayne Anthony. |
|
Light aqua with no embossing and MLOD. |
Blue aqua with no embossing and large round dome.
|
|
RD
149959 in aqua -
Tommy Bolack. |
RD 149959 in jade green milkglass
-
Jim Meyer. |
|
The CD 127 pre-dates the later "blobtop" style. |
Transitioning the early telegraph style (CD 127) and the CD 126 is the CD
126.1 style which saw an increase in the size of the dome and wire groove, but
retaining the straight skirt. |
Dave Kelly joins his dad on many hunts. Here
he proudly displays a blob top
that had
its surface etched by blowing desert sands.
|